Mantello Cigars Premium Cigar Humidor

Curated from 43 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 19, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6

Mantello Cigars Premium Cigar Humidor

Brand: Mantello Cigars
Price: $39
Snoop Score:
2.3
Sentiment
0.0
Popularity
0.0
Technical
3.4
Buy on Amazon for $39See All Humidors Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The Premium Cigar Humidor by Mantello Cigars is an elegantly designed storage solution for 25-50 cigars, crafted from genuine Spanish cedar wood. This humidor features a glass top, hygrometer, humidifier, and a movable divider, ensuring optimal humidity control while elevating your cigar collection's presentation. Feedback from users highlights concerns about the quality of the materials and humidity control, with one user noting, "there’s a reason the best manufacturers in the world largely avoid glass tops and externally mounted hygrometers; you're just begging for humidity leakage." While some appreciate its organization and aesthetic, potential buyers should consider the mixed reviews regarding durability and humidification performance before purchasing. In conclusion, while the Premium Cigar Humidor offers a stylish way to store cigars, its quality concerns and performance issues may deter serious cigar enthusiasts and those seeking reliability in humidity control.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Humidors

Made a cigar humidor for a buddys wedding present

Insightful Chatter

I like the organization and protection aspect but concerned about the non-cedar parts and the untrustworthy seller.

Negative Feedback
Product
2.3
Mantello Cigars Premium Cigar Humidor
Buy on Amazon for $39
Home Display
1 / 10
Cigar Preservation
1 / 10
Gift Choice
1 / 10
Travel and Office Use
8 / 10
See how this compares to all Humidors

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Concerns about veneer material and mold development
“I like the organization and protection aspect but concerned about the non-cedar parts and the untrustworthy seller.”➕
“No mold issues that I've seen but very curious about everyone's opinion here as well...”➕
“It smells like it’s cedar to me haha.”➕
“Mine's doing fine, with humidity at 67%.”➕
Concerns about cedar tray utility
“No benefit other than imparting cedar flavor/scent IMO.”➕
Humidity leakage concerns due to glass top and hygrometer
“There’s a reason the best manufacturers in the world largely avoid glass tops and externally mounted hygrometers; you're just begging for humidity leakage.”➕
Concerns about inconsistent quality at this price point
“At this price point why not cut to the chase and get something that is really good.”➕
Poor humidification results in wooden humidors
“Yeah just skip the wooden humidors. Not worth the trouble.”➕
Concerns about shipping delays
“It is taking a very long time to ship. I think the price makes it worth a shot.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
Velieta Electric Cigar HumidorVelieta Electric Cigar Humidor$249
9.4
DetailsBuy
RACHING 330L Cigar Climate Control CabinetRACHING 330L Cigar Climate Control Cabinet$2399
9.1
DetailsBuy
COOL KNIGHT Cigar Humidor CabinetCOOL KNIGHT Cigar Humidor Cabinet$129
8.1
DetailsBuy
Flauno Cigar HumidorFlauno Cigar Humidor$23
7.5
DetailsBuy
LIHTUN Cigar Humidor CabinetLIHTUN Cigar Humidor Cabinet$92
7.2
DetailsBuy
XIFEI Acrylic Humidor Jar with Humidifier and HygrometerXIFEI Acrylic Humidor Jar with Humidifier and Hygrometer$18
6.9
DetailsBuy
TUTUNES&Wudytim Cigar HumidorTUTUNES&Wudytim Cigar Humidor$51
6.7
DetailsBuy
Manastin Electric Cigar HumidorManastin Electric Cigar Humidor$349
6.3
DetailsBuy
GLENCREAG MET-1031 Cigar Humidor CabinetGLENCREAG MET-1031 Cigar Humidor Cabinet$99
5.9
DetailsBuy
NEEDONE Humidor 16L Electric Cooler for 100 CigarsNEEDONE Humidor 16L Electric Cooler for 100 Cigars$139
5.8
DetailsBuy
OTAKOKIT Cigar Humidor, Modern Glass Top Cedar BoxOTAKOKIT Cigar Humidor, Modern Glass Top Cedar Box$32
5.7
DetailsBuy
Woodronic Cigar Humidor for 25 Counts with HygrometerWoodronic Cigar Humidor for 25 Counts with Hygrometer$19
5.7
DetailsBuy
Nidivey Handmade Cigar HumidorNidivey Handmade Cigar Humidor$27
5.3
DetailsBuy
KingChii 16L Electric Cigar HumidorsKingChii 16L Electric Cigar Humidors$149
5.3
DetailsBuy
Marvero Cigar Humidors: Cedar Wood Humidor with HygrometerMarvero Cigar Humidors: Cedar Wood Humidor with Hygrometer$159
4.8
DetailsBuy
Mojgar Cigar Humidor CaseMojgar Cigar Humidor Case$21
4.5
DetailsBuy
Marvero Desktop Cigar Humidor CabinetMarvero Desktop Cigar Humidor Cabinet$149
4.5
DetailsBuy
FANKAI Cigar Humidor - Full Glass Top Cigar BoxFANKAI Cigar Humidor - Full Glass Top Cigar Box$23
4.4
DetailsBuy
Bald Eagle Handmade Cigar HumidorBald Eagle Handmade Cigar Humidor$29
3.7
DetailsBuy
Mantello Cigars Premium Cigar HumidorMantello Cigars Premium Cigar Humidor$39
2.3
DetailsBuy
SEMKONT Cigar Humidor CabinetSEMKONT Cigar Humidor Cabinet$139
1.5
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Impressive craftsmanship showcased in humidor project
“Made a cigar humidor for a buddys wedding present”➕
“I'm extremely impressed with your craftsmanship! Fantastic project and it looks amazing!”➕
“Finally something not made out of used pallets. Beautiful work!”➕
“/r/cigars would appreciate this, I am sure!”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Interest in woodworking and creating high-end projects
“I think something like this would be very cool for a good friend of mine getting married next May.”➕
Discussion about alternative storage solutions
“I am out of space.”➕
“If you still need more room than the largest Sistema offers, look into using a cooler!”➕
“Might give the Brilliance a try.”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Discussion on seasoning techniques for beginners
“Did I mess up seasoning? I put in one 84% boxed seasoning kit in there.”➕
Reference to the importance of proper humidor maintenance
“Gave a long answer on humidors here…”➕
Discussion about the reliability of product reviews
“Fakespot detects fake reviews, fake products and unreliable sellers using AI.”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Cases
Premium Cigar Accessory Cases for Humidors
Premium Cigar Accessory Cases for Humidors
Explore Cases
Punches
High Quality Punch Sets for Precision Pin Removal
High Quality Punch Sets for Precision Pin Removal
Explore Punches