NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil

Curated from 94 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: January 29, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6
Product Image 7

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil

Brand: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Price: $5
Snoop Score:
6.4
Sentiment
5.7
Popularity
6.7
Technical
6.2
Buy on Amazon for $5See All Eyeliner Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil is a retractable, creamy, and intensely pigmented eyeliner designed to deliver a bold, defined look without the hassle of sharpening. It glides on smoothly, offering a versatile option that can transition from a natural daytime look to a dramatic evening statement in just a twist. Consumer chatter reveals a polarized sentiment: while many rave about its smooth, super dark application with one user exclaiming, “it is the BEST eyeliner i’ve ever found, and i’ve been through many,” others bemoan issues like dry, inconsistent formulas and leaking problems that leave them frustrated. The discussion is peppered with practical tips about using a regular pencil sharpener, highlighting both its innovative design and its shortcomings. Overall, despite mixed feedback, the product stands out in its category for its high pigmentation and ease of use, though it might not be for everyone given the variability noted by users. For those who value precision and bold color payoff, it comes recommended, yet potential buyers should be aware of the consistency issues mentioned in community reviews.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Eyeliner

I love the NYX epic liner personally bc it's super dark and comes out really smooth.

Positive Feedback

I had a bad allergic reaction to this pencil and should probably just toss it.

Negative Feedback
Product
6.4
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil
Buy on Amazon for $5
Everyday Wear
5 / 10
Special Events
5 / 10
Active Lifestyles
5 / 10
Quick Application & Touch-Ups
10 / 10
See how this compares to all Eyeliner

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Super dark and smooth application
“I love the NYX epic liner personally bc it's super dark and comes out really smooth.”➕
“Lasts all day, nice precise line, and comes off easily with soap and water.”➕
Doesn't smudge easily
“The NYX epic ink has only smudged on me once and that was because it was a very very hot day.”➕
Beginner-friendly
“I love the NYX epic liner, can’t fault it!”➕
Easy to use for tapered looks
“I love the shape of the tip, it makes it super easy to taper my lash line right into my thick wing without having to deal with any brushes or shaky lines.”➕
“i found this to be the easiest eyeliner to use and i love how it turns out.”➕
Retractable design allows easy application
“I'm kind of broke and disappointed thinking these are so short-lived.”➕
“You can definitely sharpen these with a regular pencil sharpener:)”➕
“I’ve used this maybe 5 times and it’s already almost gone!”➕
“You literally sharpen the plastic.”➕
Easy sharpening method revealed
“Some of these you can actually sharpen with a sharpener even though it's a plastic like material.”➕
“Omg same! So happy to know this, was about to throw one out.”➕
“Omg does this work for the jumbo sized white eyeliner pencils?!?! I thought it had to have more uses but I had no clue there was a special pencil sharpener :0”➕
“You totally do not need a special pencil sharpener to sharpen the jumbo eye pencil, a standard makeup sharpener with a large hole will work.”➕
Super pigmented and matte finish
“it is the BEST eyeliner i’ve ever found, and i’ve been through many.”➕
“Cleansing balm for the win!”➕
Does not smudge easily
“try eye makeup remover ! specifically the ones that have two layers and need you to shake the bottle before use !”➕
Long-lasting and smudge-proof
“it doesn’t come off even if you rub your eye accidentally.”➕
Easy to use for beginners
“I got home, eager to try it out, and it's HOT GARBAGE.”➕
High-quality formulation
“I like all of the NYX makeup I have tried.”➕
Hope the formulas better.
“Hope the formulas better. These used to crack off when I got into them.”➕
Colors are pretty.
“But the colors are pretty.”➕
Best drugstore brand for daily use
“NYX is the best drugstore brand I've found for daily use.”➕
Easiest to use in terms of ink flow and consistency
“The nyx epic ink liner is the easiest to use in terms of ink flow and consistency.”➕
Lasts a long time without drying out
“Intense sweat and rubbing would let it come off but other than that it's my go to for the last year.”➕
“So definitely the longest lasting eyeliner I've had.”➕
Some products are very pigmented and long-lasting
“pigmented, matte without being drying, and stays on throughout the day, even after eating.”➕
“Very pigmented and it stays where you put it!”➕
Some users enjoy their existing products
“Am I the only one who enjoyed some of their products?”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Bad allergic reactions reported
“I had a bad allergic reaction to this pencil and should probably just toss it.”➕
Difficult to remove
“I’ve had great luck w Clinique’s Take The Day Off Balm.”➕
Brown formula is dry and inconsistent
“It’s been dried since I got it.”➕
“I bought the brown and absolutely hated it.”➕
Product leaks and makes a mess
“it’s always leaking and makes a mess on the tip, or my eye if I’m not careful.”➕
“the lid pops off in my make up bag and it dries up.”➕
“yes mine has leaked too!! the worst!”➕
Product leaks and bleeds
“It bleeds everywhere and anywhere, it also leaks from the start of the applicator.”➕
“Same thing happened with me, bled all over the place.”➕
Recent pens have bled a lot
“Honestly if you're sick of them drying up, get a good fine tip liner brush and some gel or water activated liner, it has done wonders for me.”➕
Lack of consistency across products
“I feel like they lack consistency.”➕
“That said, consistency is even lacking for individual products.”➕
“I agree about lacking consistency.”➕
Higher prices are causing dissatisfaction
“for them to up their prices I think is really really going to hurt them because they just don’t compete imo with other brands in their new price range.”➕
Frequent discontinuation of products
“They seem to have a ton of different lines with very little difference between them, and seem to discontinue stuff fairly often.”➕
Bad odor from the product
“Mine literally smell so bad I thought it was just me”➕
“I'd rather not put that in my eyes honestly hahaha”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner - Blackwet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner - Black$2
8.2
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner PencilMAYBELLINE Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner Pencil$6
7.8
DetailsBuy
L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Original Mechanical Pencil EyelinerL'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Original Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner$7
7.7
DetailsBuy
e.l.f. Expert Liquid Linere.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner$5
7.6
DetailsBuy
COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Liquid Eyeliner, Black OnyxCOVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Liquid Eyeliner, Black Onyx$6
7.1
DetailsBuy
REVLON ColorStay Pencil EyelinerREVLON ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner$7
7.0
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip EyelinerMAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner$8
7.0
DetailsBuy
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Blacke.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Black$5
6.8
DetailsBuy
COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil, Black OnyxCOVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil, Black Onyx$6
6.8
DetailsBuy
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil Brown DenimL'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil Brown Denim$6
6.7
DetailsBuy
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyelinerwet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner$2
6.5
DetailsBuy
Too Faced Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof EyelinerToo Faced Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Eyeliner$26
6.5
DetailsBuy
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye PencilNYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil$5
6.4
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE Master Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Defining BlackMAYBELLINE Master Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Defining Black$8
6.2
DetailsBuy
wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Baby's Got Blackwet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Baby's Got Black$0
6.1
DetailsBuy
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Brown, Vegan FormulaNYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Brown, Vegan Formula$9
5.9
DetailsBuy
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner 001 BlackRimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner 001 Black$4
5.5
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner, Ebony Black, 0.01 OunceMAYBELLINE Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner, Ebony Black, 0.01 Ounce$6
5.4
DetailsBuy
L'Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner BlackL'Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner Black$8
4.7
DetailsBuy
Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Brown TopazAlmay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Brown Topaz$6
4.6
DetailsBuy
e.l.f. Liquid Eyeliner, Jet Blacke.l.f. Liquid Eyeliner, Jet Black$3
4.6
DetailsBuy
L'Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Super Slim Liquid EyelinerL'Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner$7
4.2
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil Waterproof EyelinerMAYBELLINE Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner$7
4.1
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE New York Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Waterproof Eyeliner, Pitch BrownMAYBELLINE New York Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Waterproof Eyeliner, Pitch Brown$8
3.9
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner, Blackest BlackMAYBELLINE New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner, Blackest Black$8
3.9
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Brown Eyeliner PencilMAYBELLINE Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Brown Eyeliner Pencil$6
3.7
DetailsBuy
COVERGIRL Ink It By Perfect Point Plus Waterproof EyelinerCOVERGIRL Ink It By Perfect Point Plus Waterproof Eyeliner$14
3.5
DetailsBuy
e.l.f. Eyeliner Pen with FeltTip Applicator, Blacke.l.f. Eyeliner Pen with FeltTip Applicator, Black$3
3.1
DetailsBuy
MAYBELLINE Define-A-Line Eyeliner, Brownish BlackMAYBELLINE Define-A-Line Eyeliner, Brownish Black$5
2.9
DetailsBuy
Physicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner - Ultra BlackPhysicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner - Ultra Black$8
2.9
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Discussion about eyeliner types and differences
“make sure u put the lid back on carefeully as I've ruined about 2 of these before because the bristles were sticking out :(”➕
“I think it’s the Epic Wear Liner, not the Epic Ink Liner, but I’m not sure if the brush is the only difference or if the formula is also diff.”➕
Discussion about the rebranding to 'NYX Professional Makeup'
“I personally think it is very strange because the quality is simply not there.”➕
“Honestly, it’s going to have to take a lot for me to actually buy more from Nyx, because the rising prices and lack of quality aren’t worth it.”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Tips for sharpening using freezer
“PUT IT IN THE FREEZER FIRST FOR LIKE 20 MINS and THEN sharpen it!!!!!”➕
“you could also try sticking your pencils in the freezer for a bit before sharpening; that might help!”➕
Discussion about sharpening techniques
“Def had a face palm moment when I learned they could be sharpened.”➕
“What am I doing wrong?”➕
“The soft plastic glides through the sharpener so well too.”➕
“There’s always more product somewhere lol.”➕
Suggestions for makeup removal techniques
“Oil based micellar water works. I personally use coconut on a cotton round, let it sit on my eye for a bit to loosen it up.”➕
Curiosity about tools for jumbo sized pencils
“Thanks for unearthing this core memory, OP. You’re not the only one struggling with NYX packaging.”➕
“The Urban Decay Grindhouse Sharpener ($10 frickin dollars) is amazing with the fat & thin pencils, both wood and plastic.”➕
Launch of new mechanical pencil liners in jewel tones
“NYX Cosmetics Vivid Rich Mechanical Pencil Liners have launched.”➕
“The brand has brought back their mechanical pencil liners combining them with their vivid rich line in 12 jewel toned shades.”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Comparison to other brands
“Looking for a drugstore beginner friendly liquid eyeliner that doesn't bleed and smudge preferably with a felt tip.”➕
“I only use NYX and Stila liquid liner.”➕
“the nyx one is a good substitute tho.”➕
Tips for maintaining eyeliner quality
“If you wet your fingers and straighten them out and let it sit for a day you should be ok!”➕
“Look online using the search term dual eyeliner pencil sharpener.”➕
Curiosity about UK availability.
“I hope they will be available in UK soon. I wonder what quality is going to be like.”➕
Comparisons to other brands
“Honestly, the best brown liquid eyeliner that I’ve found is the BFF one by Colourpop.”➕
Comparison to Maybelline eyeliner
“I have used different eyeliner pen felt tips and none of them last as long as I want them to or hope them to!”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Discussion on storage affecting performance
“It’s meant to stored right side up, no upsided down!”➕
Concern about quality assurance
“sucks that this is an issue though, like this would be such an easy thing to spot in quality assurance surely?!”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Eyeshadow
Alluring Eyeshadow Trends for Makeup Enthusiasts
Alluring Eyeshadow Trends for Makeup Enthusiasts
Explore Eyeshadow
Mascara
Top Mascara Picks for Voluminous and Lengthened Lashes
Top Mascara Picks for Voluminous and Lengthened Lashes
Explore Mascara
Concealer
Top Concealers for Flawless Eyes
Top Concealers for Flawless Eyes
Explore Concealer