Max Protection Max Pro 1 Screw Thick Card Holder

Curated from 43 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 27, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2

Max Protection Max Pro 1 Screw Thick Card Holder

Brand: Max Protection
Price: $17
Snoop Score:
6.4
Sentiment
8.0
Popularity
9.9
Technical
4.3
Buy on Amazon for $17See All Screwdowns Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The Max Pro 1 Screw Thick Card Holder is designed specifically for collectors looking to securely store their valuable jersey and memorabilia cards. With a robust two-piece design and brass screw feature, this holder can accommodate cards up to 50 points, ensuring optimal protection. Consumer feedback emphasizes the card holder’s impressive commitment to protection, with quotes highlighting that "this method is really overkill, with a total of five layers protecting the card," showcasing the product's reliability. Additionally, users appreciate features like protection from sun exposure, stating, "the tint I believe is to protect your cards from sun exposure," which adds to its appeal for serious collectors. Overall, the Max Pro 1 Screw Thick Card Holder is highly recommended for those in the card collecting community, particularly for individuals seeking intense protection for their valuable cards despite some concerns regarding case appearance and potential card damage during installation.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Screwdowns

My most valuable cards are in screw-down cases, but those get scratched so much.

Positive Feedback

The case looks crappy but the card is perfect

Negative Feedback
Product
6.4
Max Protection Max Pro 1 Screw Thick Card Holder
Buy on Amazon for $17
Trading Card Protection
6 / 10
Collectible Display
6 / 10
Postcard and Photo Storage
4 / 10
Organized Collection Management
6 / 10
See how this compares to all Screwdowns

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Provides a secure storage option for valuable cards
“My most valuable cards are in screw-down cases, but those get scratched so much.”➕
“Which would you prefer? Ultra pro screwdowns?one touch? Or just toploader?”➕
“Keep those in a waterproof camping case for long term storage.”➕
“Now it's your turn. What do we have in KC or surrounding area that we'd band together to protect? (Funny or serious answers.)”➕
Includes features to protect cards from sun exposure
“The tint I believe is to protect your cards from sun exposure.”➕
Intense build quality for protection
“This thing is intense!”➕
Impressive commitment to card protection
“this method is really overkill, with a total of five layers protecting the card.”➕
“Woah, your commitment to protecting these photocards is commendable, this is impressively overboard in the best way possible”➕
“i just like mine individually wrapped and was trying to find the best fitting sleeves to do so :)”➕
Provides protection for valuable cards
“Finally removed after 31 years in a screw down!!!”➕
“Absolutely send in for grading just for the protection of it.”➕
“Protection most important. Not planning on selling.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Case appearance is subpar
“The case looks crappy but the card is perfect”➕
Screwdowns can damage your card when twisting the screw
“This is what I do. Screw downs can actually damage your card when twisting the screw if you really feel like a magnetic case is fine but I’ve been using double sleeved into top loaders and my cards are fine”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
BCW 1 Screw Card Holder - 20 PTBCW 1 Screw Card Holder - 20 PT$13
8.9
DetailsBuy
BCW Screwdown 2-Card HolderBCW Screwdown 2-Card Holder$8
8.8
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro 1" Thick Lucite Screwdown Trading Card DisplayUltra Pro 1" Thick Lucite Screwdown Trading Card Display$22
8.5
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro 9-Card Black Frame Screwdown Card HolderUltra Pro 9-Card Black Frame Screwdown Card Holder$18
7.6
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro MLB 8X10 Black ScrewdownUltra Pro MLB 8X10 Black Screwdown$18
7.3
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro Single-Screwdown Holder for Thick Trading CardsUltra Pro Single-Screwdown Holder for Thick Trading Cards$4
7.3
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro 2-Card Black Frame Screwdown HolderUltra Pro 2-Card Black Frame Screwdown Holder$11
7.0
DetailsBuy
BCW 5x7 Photo Screwdown HolderBCW 5x7 Photo Screwdown Holder$8
6.4
DetailsBuy
Max Protection Max Pro 1 Screw Thick Card HolderMax Protection Max Pro 1 Screw Thick Card Holder$17
6.4
DetailsBuy
UPro 2-Pack Ultra Pro Screw Down Series 1/2" LuciteUPro 2-Pack Ultra Pro Screw Down Series 1/2" Lucite$19
6.3
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro Gaming Generic Screwdown - 5x7Ultra Pro Gaming Generic Screwdown - 5x7$7
4.9
DetailsBuy
Generic 2024 Panini Instant Cooper DeJean #287 CardGeneric 2024 Panini Instant Cooper DeJean #287 Card$17
4.7
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro 1/4 Non-Recessed ScrewdownUltra Pro 1/4 Non-Recessed Screwdown$4
4.3
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro 3 Card Holder ScrewdownUltra Pro 3 Card Holder Screwdown$19
4.2
DetailsBuy
Ultra Pro Stor Safe 4x6 ScrewdownUltra Pro Stor Safe 4x6 Screwdown$8
4.2
DetailsBuy
Polieres Trominax Final ScrewdownPolieres Trominax Final ScrewdownN/A
2.4
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Overkill protection methods in card collecting
“Wow, even as a Magic: The Gathering player, this is quite overkill (except for Power 9) but I commend you for committing to this method.”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Discussion on grading importance
“You have to grade it. The difference between a non graded card and a low graded card is still way in the advantage of grading.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Nostalgic reference to old storage methods
“yeah, those were pretty popular for storage back in the day”➕
Comment on card's worth despite condition
“I've never even heard of the player...I understand it may be old and in good condition but I don't think it's worth much.”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Albums
Elegant Card Storage & Display Albums for Collectibles
Elegant Card Storage & Display Albums for Collectibles
Explore Albums