Dr. Talbot's Gas + Colic Relief Liquid Medicine

Curated from 64 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 20, 2025

Dr. Talbot's Gas + Colic Relief Liquid Medicine

Brand: Dr. Talbot's
Price: $8
Snoop Score:
5.8
Sentiment
5.0
Popularity
9.2
Technical
5.2

Snoop's Take

Dr. Talbot's Gas + Colic Relief Liquid Medicine is a natural remedy designed to quickly ease gas pain and colic discomfort in infants. It leverages a blend of homeopathic ingredients and cell salts along with natural fruit juices to deliver fast acting relief in a tasty apple juice flavor. Consumer sentiment is as polarized as you might expect; one exultant user proclaims, 'They WORK! They REALLY WORK. Think of the BABIES, people!', while skeptics dub it nothing more than an old fashioned snake oil remedy. The dialogue captures both robust endorsements and sharp critiques, highlighting a blend of genuine relief and amusing skepticism. Overall, the product earns a nod if you favor a natural, non-medication approach for infant discomfort, though the snark in community reviews suggests you’ll need to weigh its benefits against its trendy, if controversial, positioning.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Colic & Gas Relief

They WORK! They REALLY WORK. Think of the BABIES, people!

Positive Feedback

Lol, I actually see "Dr." Talbot more as an old fashioned snake oil salesman.

Negative Feedback
Product
5.8
Dr. Talbot's Gas + Colic Relief Liquid Medicine
Instant Gas Relief
4 / 10
Soothing Colic Symptoms
8 / 10
Non-Medication Approach
3 / 10
On-The-Go Comfort
4 / 10
See how this compares to all Colic & Gas Relief

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Product appears to provide effective colic relief
They WORK! They REALLY WORK. Think of the BABIES, people!

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Perceived as a snake oil remedy
Lol, I actually see "Dr." Talbot more as an old fashioned snake oil salesman.

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
uhfi Gas and Colic Reliever for Babiesuhfi Gas and Colic Reliever for Babies$7
7.3
DetailsBuy
ADILAIDUN 20 Count Gas and Colic Reliever for BabiesADILAIDUN 20 Count Gas and Colic Reliever for Babies$7
6.6
DetailsBuy
MYLICON Infants Gas Relief Drops for Infants and BabiesMYLICON Infants Gas Relief Drops for Infants and Babies$9
6.2
DetailsBuy
Frida Baby Windi Gas PasserFrida Baby Windi Gas Passer$12
6.1
DetailsBuy
Dr. Talbot's Gas + Colic Relief Liquid MedicineDr. Talbot's Gas + Colic Relief Liquid Medicine$8
5.8
DetailsBuy
comfheat Colic and Gas Relief for Newborns and Infantscomfheat Colic and Gas Relief for Newborns and Infants$12
5.0
DetailsBuy
Heigoeost Baby Colic and Gas Relief WrapHeigoeost Baby Colic and Gas Relief Wrap$13
4.6
DetailsBuy
BioGaia Protectis Baby Probiotic DropsBioGaia Protectis Baby Probiotic Drops$17
3.0
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Preference for simethicone‐based gas drops over gripe water
We use mylicon brand specifically, and we feel like it does work.
Most pediatricians recommend against gripe water since it isn’t regulated and probably doesn’t work.
Good luck!
Gripe water has **no** scientific backing, but simethicone does.
Detailed discussion on CRISPR and gene editing research
The first part is absolutely possible.
Just because we have a lot to learn before we 'should' try this doesn't mean that some won't dive in head first anyway.
I'm all for human enhancement. I really am.
I would say that anybody that has a genetic disease would opt to not pass it to their children even if a cure was not possible.

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Parenting and mental health challenges
I just want it all to be over. I wish I hadn’t had a baby and doomed her to this shitty existence with a shitty parent.
I'm sure you're doing your best, even if it doesn't feel that way.
I’ve started seeing a therapist during the pandemic and it seems as though a lot of insurance companies are paying the whole bill for telehealth therapy.
Have you had her ears checked for infection?
Discussion of unconventional and snake oil remedies
That shit made me feel like the incredible hulk. Probably one of the worst feelings I’ve ever had and I do not recommend it.
Even mixing alcohol and caffeine can be a dangerous combination, such as Four Loko.
Wake and Bake is just getting high as soon as you wake up!
Teething remedy debates
So far, it seems, the best remedy for teething is cold/chewy toys and Tylenol.
Not worth the risk in my opinion.
It's BS. Almost definitely fake amber to begin with.

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Confusing references to product parts and bottle compatibility
The crazy thing is, these are just parts for if you already own the bottles.
Infant bottle recommendations discussion
I’m debating on sticking with my Dr.Brown, Avent or Lansinoh.
For as much as bottle preference is hyped up, bottle refusal is way more common IMO.
I love my Doc Browns glass bottles!
Just surprised it wasnt more marketed :)

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Humorous portrayal of Dr. Talbot's in a parody style
He's the baby butt bugle Doc , Doctor T.
Shared experiences and emotional support among parents of colicky or reflux babies
This post really helped me and made me feel better.
But the smiles are worth it.
Like, I was a freaking wreck on Sunday.
I’m dying.
Challenges faced by new parents in infant care
The five S’s worked really well for us.
So I will definitely not downplay how hard the beginning was, but it absolutely does get easier.
Just gotta get through the 6-8 week period. It’s where peak fussiness typically hits.
Hang in there. It gets better.
Issues with baby bottles and leakage prompting exploration of alternatives
We’ve tried everything and nothing has worked every feeding we have about an ounce pour out of the bottle via the collar area.
Couldnt stand dr. Browns, switched to Mam bottles.
Had an awesome experience with the Phillips Avent bottles.
Infant bottle experiences for colicky babies
He’s now using Philips Avent Natural and it’s made a world of a difference.
It’s all we’ve ever used and he took to them pretty well!

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Thermometers
Top Thermometers for Baby and Family Health
Top Thermometers for Baby and Family Health
Nasal Aspirators
Top Nasal Aspirators for Babies: Safe, Effective, and Innovative
Top Nasal Aspirators for Babies: Safe, Effective, and Innovative
Nasal Tweezers
The Best Nasal Tweezers for Gentle Baby Care
The Best Nasal Tweezers for Gentle Baby Care