American Crew Men's Hair Pomade

Curated from 52 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: January 17, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6
Product Image 7
Product Image 8
Product Image 9

American Crew Men's Hair Pomade

Brand: AMERICAN CREW
Price: $12
Snoop Score:
5.0
Sentiment
2.5
Popularity
1.7
Technical
7.0
Buy on Amazon for $12See All Pomades Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

American Crew Men's Hair Pomade is a styling product designed to provide heavy hold and high shine for various hair types, particularly for short to medium lengths. Consumer feedback highlights a mix of satisfaction and disappointment, with some praising its smoothness and ease of washing out, as one user noted, "it feels like oil but it washes out easily," while others criticize its hold, stating that "it just disappears out of my hair after a few hours." Despite some positive aspects, such as a pleasant scent and decent shine, the overall sentiment leans towards caution, as many users feel it underperforms, especially in humid conditions. Given the mixed reviews, potential buyers should consider their specific hair types and styling needs before purchasing. While the pomade offers some desirable features like a nice scent and ease of use, the recurring complaints about its effectiveness and hold suggest that there may be better alternatives available. If you prioritize hold over shine or are looking for a more reliable option, you may want to explore other brands that receive more favorable comparisons.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Pomades

I actually really like almost every aspect of it, especially the smoothness it gives my hair (I hate products that make my hair hard/crusty).

Positive Feedback

it just disappears out of my hair after a few hours.

Negative Feedback
Product
5.0
American Crew Men's Hair Pomade
Buy on Amazon for $12
Everyday Grooming
1 / 10
Professional Styling
9 / 10
Special Occasions
10 / 10
Versatile Application
2 / 10
See how this compares to all Pomades

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Smoothness without hardness
“I actually really like almost every aspect of it, especially the smoothness it gives my hair (I hate products that make my hair hard/crusty).”➕
“It feels like oil but it washes out easily. It doesn’t harden up either.”➕
Pleasant scent
“It smells good and that’s the only redeeming trait.”➕
Easy to wash out
“It also washes out super easy because it’s water based.”➕
Wide range and accessibility
“I started with American Crew due to its wide range and accessibility.”➕
Decent performance despite criticisms
“It's really expensive but honestly it's quite good.”➕
Good shine
“I like the shine it gives though but the hold is terrible.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Poor hold after a few hours
“it just disappears out of my hair after a few hours.”➕
“Their pomade is pretty poor.”➕
Underwhelming performance
“American crew whip Who has tried the "American Crew Whip" pomade light hold/natural shine and gives ”➕
“If there's anything guaranteed by American Crew, it's that it'll be underwhelming.”➕
Weak hold for thick hair
“Crew certainly is not adequate on its own and isn't even the best mixed but so far, it kinda works.”➕
American Crew products have poor ingredients and performance.
“I don’t think anything American Crew is worth it.”➕
“American Crew products have horrible ingredients, just okay performance, and are far overpriced.”➕
Quality control issues with product consistency
“As you can see their quality control is clearly bad.”➕
“Is this normal? What's the difference?”➕
Product has poor effectiveness
“I dont know why but its really bad and doing almost notbing just making my hair look bad.”➕
Concerns about product authenticity from online orders
“My only conclusion is that, in an attempt to increase profits, Revlon has modified the formula and gone cheap on both the production and packaging.”➕
“I don't recall the product being off yellow/orange before either but.... maybe I'm just confusing it with another product.”➕
Concerns about formula change or authenticity
“In recent years however, as I'm sure many others will agree, something has changed.”➕
Comparison to other products being better
“I think Night Rider by Kevin Murphy has been stated to be a better version of ACF before now.”➕
“You'll quickly notice how ACF is crap next to these.”➕
“IMO better than American crew since it washes out and off your hands much easier but holds just as well.”➕
Overpriced compared to alternatives
“American crew is okay but way to expensive for what it is.”➕
“It’s okay, but for the price, it’s terrible.”➕
Product loses hold quickly in humidity
“a lot of humidity and heat can break them down and cause them to lose hold quickly.”➕
“In the hot heat i sweat a lot and my hair just kind of loses hold and what not.”➕
“the product doesn’t essentially disappear like most gel pomades.”➕
Underwhelming performance for medium hold
“There’s literally a ton of great options out there superior to American Crew.”➕
Poor effectiveness of American Crew products
“American Crew products aren't very good in general.”➕
“It was terrible the scent, the hold nothing good about it.”➕
Perception of American Crew being overpriced
“Fiber grease blows them all out of the water.”➕
American Crew products compared unfavorably to alternatives
“In this community American Crew products are generally considered to not be actual good products, and from experience, that is so true.”➕
Poor hold for thicker hair types
“I remember, years ago, feeling quite disillusioned with American Crew.”➕
Considered inferior to other products
“Honestly the closest I have found that is better but feels and acts the same is Lockharts Water Based.”➕
American Crew products are generally not very good
“Know of any cheaper alternatives to American Crew fiber? No text content”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
Organski Professional PomadeOrganski Professional Pomade$18
8.0
DetailsBuy
Suavecito Pomade Firme (Strong) Hold 4 ozSuavecito Pomade Firme (Strong) Hold 4 oz$14
7.9
DetailsBuy
Organski Professional PomadeOrganski Professional Pomade$18
6.8
DetailsBuy
Suavecito Pomade Matte (No Shine) Formula 4 ozSuavecito Pomade Matte (No Shine) Formula 4 oz$14
6.5
DetailsBuy
Suavecito Pomade Original For Men 4 ozSuavecito Pomade Original For Men 4 oz$14
6.3
DetailsBuy
Redken Brews Cream Pomade For MenRedken Brews Cream Pomade For Men$22
6.1
DetailsBuy
BYRD Hair Matte Pomade - Medium HoldBYRD Hair Matte Pomade - Medium Hold$28
5.9
DetailsBuy
Old Spice Classic Pomade for Men, Medium Hold with Low ShineOld Spice Classic Pomade for Men, Medium Hold with Low Shine$8
5.7
DetailsBuy
Generic 𝒮𝒽𝑜𝓅 Nourishing Hair Pomade - Pack 1Generic 𝒮𝒽𝑜𝓅 Nourishing Hair Pomade - Pack 1$17
5.7
DetailsBuy
Suavecito Suavecita Pomade for WomenSuavecito Suavecita Pomade for Women$14
5.2
DetailsBuy
American Crew Men's Hair PomadeAmerican Crew Men's Hair Pomade$12
5.0
DetailsBuy
Baxter of California Clay Pomade Firm Hold / Matte Finish Hair PomadeBaxter of California Clay Pomade Firm Hold / Matte Finish Hair Pomade$20
4.3
DetailsBuy
Lottando Organic PomadeLottando Organic Pomade$25
3.9
DetailsBuy
Generic Jamaican Black Castor Oil Hair PomadeGeneric Jamaican Black Castor Oil Hair Pomade$14
0.7
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Different hair types respond variably to products
“Firstly, everyone has different hair so what works for one person may not work for you.”➕
Looking for higher-quality ingredients in pomades
“I’m now looking for a product with higher-quality ingredients.”➕
“I tend to stick with minimal, no chemicals.”➕
“A good Pomade will be already infused with natural oils and extracts.”➕
Discussion about different American Crew pomades
“Are there two different American Crew pomades?”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Suggestions for alternative pomades
“Look for unorthodox water-based pomades.”➕
Looking for superior alternatives to American Crew
“ACP is honestly one of my favorite products I’ve tried so far, but I know some of you are bound to have superior recommendations.”➕
Suggestions for alternative pomades.
“What products would you suggest if now American Crew?”➕
Searching for superior alternatives to American Crew
“This is the answer. My search to find a replacement for American Crew fiber is finally over.”➕
Recommendations for alternative pomades
“What pomade do you recommend?”➕
Different products may work variably for individuals with curly hair
“So everything I’ve read regarding which pomades are best for curly hair is not true or not completely accurate?”➕
Discussion about alternative pomades for better hold
“When I first apply my hair is nicer and wavy but then in about 10 min the curls retract.”➕
Discussion about the effectiveness of American Crew vs alternatives
“It seems fine to me but that could just be my ignorance.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Discussion about variations in product versions
“Anyone know what was changed and how that changed hold or shine or anything else?”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Salt Water Sprays
The Best Salt Water Sprays for Effortless Beach Waves
The Best Salt Water Sprays for Effortless Beach Waves
Explore Salt Water Sprays