Hero 0Hero 1Hero 2Hero 3Hero 4Hero 5Hero 6Hero 7Hero 8Hero 9Hero 10Hero 11Hero 12Hero 13Hero 14

Top Xbox One Controller Joystick Replacements

Curated from 238 real Reddit comments and discussions across 5 products.

Refreshed on: March 22, 2025

Snoop’s Take

Controller enthusiasts on Reddit demand replacement joysticks with documented ±2–4% precision, carbon-film potentiometers tested for millions of cycles, and smooth, zero-binding motion. Top kits deliver pro-grade tolerances, guided tutorials, and wallet-friendly pricing that feels legit. The flops? Anonymous, drift-prone sticks that require nuclear-grade soldering skills and still wander off-center within months. Community sentiment skewers generic builds for compatibility blind spots, flimsy materials, and signal glitches. If you prize accuracy, longevity, and a painless install, hunt brands with transparent metrics and service-worn staff endorsements. Red flags include undocumented specs, “easy install” disclaimers that mask soldering hell, and clones that ghost mid-match.

Top Considerations Before Purchasing

Precision Tolerance Is Crucial - Choose joysticks with ±2–4% center-rest and published performance metrics.
Installation Complexity Varies - Soldering required on many kits; guided tutorials ease the process.
Compatibility Can Bite You - Verify controller model, avoid 360/PS3 units, and check game support.
Drift Risks Persist - Even high-end sticks may drift over time; plan recalibration or replacement.

All Products that we Rated

Our Winner
DIY Controller UpgradesCost-Effective RepairsExtended Controller Lifespan
JAO Automation REV2.0 Joystick Analog Stick Replacement
9.1
JAO Automation REV2.0 Joystick Analog Stick Replacement
Reddit Feedback
U
I got one on Amazon for 10 dollars and was able to fix an Xbox controller with it.
U
Hall effect joysticks do last much much longer than potentiometer joysticks from Alps or Favor, and they do feel much sm...
U
Not cool. I was banned for "griefing" by taking too long to configure my joystick controls for the helicopter.
Snoop Score Breakdown
Sentiment
9.2
Popularity
9.4
Feautures
9.0
✅ Recommended
Our Runner Up
Fixing Stick Drift
SOSS GAMING® Genuine Analog Joysticks Repair Kit for Xbox One
7.5
SOSS GAMING® Genuine Analog Joysticks Repair Kit for Xbox One
Reddit Feedback
U
Cheap solder kit and tactile switches from soss gaming on amazon could be a fun project if you’re up to repairing instea...
U
A bit of research, and it seems like hall effect joysticks solve the issue.
U
cant connect joystick sos doreamon 2 pc? Anyone know how to connect joystick on pc?? I tried using x360 but still doesn'...
Snoop Score Breakdown
Sentiment
10.0
Popularity
10.0
Feautures
5.7
✅ Recommended

Other Products the Community Recommends

Kinyanco 4PCS Replacement Joystick for Xbox One S/X Controller
6.7
Kinyanco 4PCS Replacement Joystick for Xbox One S/X Controller
Reddit Feedback
U
Worth it if you're handy with a screw driver and following instructions.
U
YES. I've replaced mine at least 4-6 times now.
U
It’s not a hard process just tedious and nerve raking if you aren’t delicate or haven’t done something like it before.
Snoop Score Breakdown
Sentiment
6.8
Popularity
9.0
Feautures
5.7
✅ Recommended
YWLRONG Joysticks Replacement for Xbox One S/X
4.3
YWLRONG Joysticks Replacement for Xbox One S/X
Reddit Feedback
U
Man this looks excellent. Check out my butch of a job on my controller.
U
It seems like a great alternative option for hall-effect joystick ones.
U
no se si es que ando perdido tema precios pero creo que estan bastante salados en ml.
Snoop Score Breakdown
Sentiment
3.3
Popularity
5.4
Feautures
4.7
✅ Recommended

Products You Will Return...

JAO Automation Premium Quality Joysticks for Xbox and PS4
3.0
JAO Automation Premium Quality Joysticks for Xbox and PS4
Reddit Feedback
U
many games either don't see it or they do see it but don't or aren't accepting inputs from it.
U
It's a cheap generic USB accessory. 8051 core inside.
U
My solution is to buy another set of encoders from Arcade Paradise, but I don’t want to run into the same issues.
Snoop Score Breakdown
Sentiment
0.0
Popularity
0.0
Feautures
5.0
❌ Not Recommended

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
JAO Automation REV2.0 Joystick Analog Stick ReplacementJAO Automation REV2.0 Joystick Analog Stick Replacement$9
9.1
DetailsBuy
SOSS GAMING® Genuine Analog Joysticks Repair Kit for Xbox OneSOSS GAMING® Genuine Analog Joysticks Repair Kit for Xbox One$16
7.5
DetailsBuy
Kinyanco 4PCS Replacement Joystick for Xbox One S/X ControllerKinyanco 4PCS Replacement Joystick for Xbox One S/X Controller$13
6.7
DetailsBuy
YWLRONG Joysticks Replacement for Xbox One S/XYWLRONG Joysticks Replacement for Xbox One S/X$11
4.3
DetailsBuy
JAO Automation Premium Quality Joysticks for Xbox and PS4JAO Automation Premium Quality Joysticks for Xbox and PS4$9
3.0
DetailsBuy

Products that are Best For...

Discover Reddit’s top joystick picks for every repair scenario. From precision upgrades to budget DIY fixes, these community favorites excel.

Fixing Stick Drift
SOSS GAMING® Genuine Analog Joysticks Repair Kit for Xbox One

The repair kit effectively addresses stick drift by allowing users to replace worn potentiometers, as highlighted in customer feedback where users mentioned successfully repairing drifting issues.

DIY Controller Upgrades
JAO Automation REV2.0 Joystick Analog Stick Replacement

The product is ideal for enthusiasts looking to upgrade their controllers with high-precision joystick modules. Feedback indicates that users appreciate the improved smoothness and control during game...

Cost-Effective Repairs
JAO Automation REV2.0 Joystick Analog Stick Replacement

Replacing joysticks with this product is a cost-effective solution compared to purchasing a new controller. Users have shared experiences of successfully repairing controllers, saving significant mone...

Extended Controller Lifespan
JAO Automation Premium Quality Joysticks for Xbox and PS4

Routine replacement of these joysticks can help extend the lifespan of controllers by maintaining performance. Despite this, the product's poor reputation for build quality and limited game compatibil...

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Flight Controls
Top PC Flight Control Accessories for Simulators
Top PC Flight Control Accessories for Simulators
Gamepads & Standard Controllers
Top PS4 Standard Gamepad Controllers
Top PS4 Standard Gamepad Controllers
Racing Wheels
Top PS5 Racing Wheel Controllers
Top PS5 Racing Wheel Controllers